Monday, December 1, 2014

Blog 13 So Hannibal Wins, Right?

As a person who studies military history, there are some lessons you learn just by reading. Don’t invade Russia during the winter as it’s where land armies go to die. A Chinese war without a million deaths is a small Chinese war. Don’t anger Vlad the Impaler. Don’t trust anyone with Khan as their last name. I figured out another lesson to add to this list; don’t fight Hannibal in a pitched battle.
So after three crushing defeats that would bring most nations easily to their knees Rome was in a bad state. Fabius’ year without a victory may have bought the Romans time to rebuild but they basically wasted it.   Varro was discredited and the majority of their forces were gone. The two legions worth of troops that escaped were sent to Sicily as punishment for retreating. Now Hannibal’s goal was to win a war where Carthage got to give the terms. [1]At this point he considered the war basically over. So he sent a group of Roman prisoners to talk to the senate about the prisoner negotiation and possibly a treaty. The Romans refused to deal with Hannibal, declaring that they were going to fight to the bitter end.[2] So basically the Romans said that they refused to surrender or lose this war.  This is basically what happened with Pyrrhus who crushed the Romans but they refused to surrender. So apparently the Romans are just a people that most Mediterranean people would find strange, people that would not give up land that they fought for in the past.
Not show is Rome getting metaphorically stomped. Although with elephant involved that's more literal. 

Similar to Pyrrhus, Hannibal now went to the south of Italy in hopes of gaining the help of southern Italians and Greeks.  The city of Capua was getting disheartened by Rome’s treatment of them. When they talked to Varro he was dismissive of them. So in Capua the pro-Carthage group gathered all the pro-Romans and locked them in a bath house where they died from the heat[3].  Hannibal, seeing a new ally, was very generous allowing them to rule themselves. However Capua refused to give Hannibal any more troops.  Hannibal’s army was fairly depleted at this point so he needed more troops. He sent his brother Mago to the Carthaginian senate to get reinforcements.  Mago walked into the assembly with a bag full of thousands of golden rings from dead cavalry men at Cannae[4]. The Carthaginian senate was pleased with this and asked if Rome was willing to negotiate. Mago told them that the Romans refused so the senate agreed to send 4000 Numidians and 40 elephants to help Hanniba[5]l.
So Rome at this point needed to rebuild and rebuild quickly. Rome changed its tax system to tax the rich more because they were extremely strapped for cash at this point. They changed the rules for who was allowed in legions. Slaves and criminals were now openly serving in the Roman legions for the first time ever. The consulship was given to experienced commanders such as Fabius Maximus who won the consulship three times.  However Hannibal was still right outside of Rome. It’s one of the great historical debates if Hannibal attacked Rome, could he have won and what would have happened.  I am not sure but if he did and won that battle, the war would have ended with Carthaginian victory.
566




[1] Miles, 280
[2] Polybius 6.58
[3] Livy 23.7
[4] Livy 23.11
[5] Livy 23.13

No comments:

Post a Comment